Blog Post #2 - Constructing Ourselves Through Technology
The Washington Post article on
Katherine provides an accurate snapshot of the technology and social media
centered life of a “typical” North American teenager today. It is clear that a
great deal of her life revolves around her smartphone and the online presence
that she is constantly working on developing. The anxieties discussed in this
article can be looked at through a Social Construction of Technology
perspective as “Katherine wants to get better at her phone. To be one of the
girls who knows what to post, how to caption it, when to like, what to comment”.
It is apparent that Katherine is an agent of this change and that while she is
dependent on her phone, she has the power to decide how she uses it. When
discussing this perspective in her book, Baym says that humans are agents of
change, not machines (44). In the article, Katherine is quotes saying: “I
decide the pictures that look good”, which emphasizes this point further. This
article also discusses the idea that Katherine’s phone is where all her friends
are all the time and therefore the place that she needs to be. Katherine’s
peers are influencing her decisions and vice versa. With new media, comes the
anxiety of losing real relationships and face-to-face interaction. If children are always on their phones, there
is a fear that they will isolate themselves and only socialize in online
settings. This becomes apparent in the article when Katherine spends her entire
drive home from school mindlessly scrolling through her phone rather than
talking to her nanny.
Katherine
explains commenting on pictures and the gratification that she feels when
people say things like she is nice or pretty. She along with many others her
age have turned Instagram into a space where your value or worth is determined
strictly by likes, comments, and followers. We have seen in other readings from
this course that there are people similar in age to Katherine who have chosen
to boycott social media altogether. I feel that because our society has become
so focused on our appearance online, we have encouraged these new platforms
like Instagram to be invented. I can relate to Katherine in the sense that I
have at some points, especially in high school cared about what people have
thought about me on my Social Media accounts like Facebook and now Instagram however,
this is because of societal pressures and my own choosing, not the technology
itself forcing me to do so. This article makes it clear that Katherine and many
others, specifically teenage girls face anxiety about their appearances and use
social media as a way to appear pretty, social, and fun. There is a fear that
these new media can bring harm to children and take away their innocence in
some ways. Rather than playing with her friends, Katherine is focused on taking
“good” pictures to post. Having a social media account at a young age can also
open up children to the potential dangers of child predators and people with
ill intentions as discussed in Chapter 2 of Baym’s novel.
I
chose this perspective because I feel that humans are the ones influencing
technology and encouraging new apps, social media platforms and phone models to
develop. We have the power to make technologies popular or to choose not to use
them at all and we use these technologies to influence society as a whole. I
strongly feel that people are becoming increasingly attached to their phones
which leads to a domino effect where new media and technologies are being
developed to further encourage this behaviour.
You did a great job making connections between how our interactions with technology impact us. What stood out to me in your post was the point you made regarding child predators. Kids are starting to use social media platforms at a very young age and that makes them even more vulnerable to child predators but this topic is not often discussed. While companies are making advancements and catering more services to younger demographics, the risks associated with online interactions seem be to overlooked or discounted.
ReplyDeleteI too chose the social construction of technology perspective as I believe that individuals are in control of how they interact and how often they interact with technology. I like how you mentioned that many of us are actively choosing to be overly concerned with how many likes, comments and followers we have on social media as this is what those around us seem to be fixed on. Our friends, siblings, classmates and society as a whole are telling us that we should always be concerned about presenting the best version of ourselves whether that be in real life or social media. Being seen as perfect and liked has always been something individuals have strived for whether technology existed or not and this unattainable perfection often leads to feeling of inadequacy and anxiety surrounding the platform. We can see how social factors emerge through technology when looking at the possible differences between how technologies are used and the impact they have in different countries hence different cultures. Had technological determinism been solely responsible for all of these issues that "arise" from its use then everyone with access to technology would have very similar tendencies and anxieties. With extreme concentration on the self rather than on others or the community, western culture has created these specific anxieties within the individual, not technology.
ReplyDelete